Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label statistics. Show all posts

9/07/2012

Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials with Time-to-Event Endpoints (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series) Review

Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials with Time-to-Event Endpoints (Chapman and Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Often in clinical trials particularly oncology trials time-to-event are the endpoints of primary interest. The endpoint could be time of death, time to remittance, time to recurrence or something else. In the recent RE-LY trial which was a stroke prevention trial the dual primary endpoints were time-to-an-occurrence of stroke and time-to-a-major bleeding episode. It seems almost always the case that the study will involved estimating these parameters based on data the include a lot of right-censoring. So the methods of survival or relaibility analysis come to play an imprtant role. Usually if the events are rare the sample size requirement will be large because power of the test of differences between two groups is dictated by the number of events which then requires large sample size s to achieve the requisite number of events. The RE-LY trial was a noninferiority trial with three equal size treatment arms and rare event occurrences. So thid trial required approximately 18000 subjects with 600 in each group. Such trials are long, difficult to administer and very expensive. So often the time-to-event endpoint is replaced by a surrogate endpoint.
Karl Peace has edited and contributed to a very timely volume on the design and analysis of time-to-event endpoints in clinical trials. This book can serve as a text or a reference for biostatisticians and particularly those involved in clinical trials, especially oncology trials. A number of authors with a lot of experience with such trials were chosen to contribute to this volume. The first 6 chapters are introductory and mostly overviews of a particular methodology. Chapter 1 by Peace,is a general overview of the topic and an introdcution to what is included in the remaining chapters. Chapter 2 by Sill and Rubinstein introduces how time-to-event endpoint trials are designed and monitored. Chapter 3 is an overview of parametric models for time-to-event distrbution by Peace and Tsai. Chapter 4 does the same for semiparametric methods (the Cox proportional hazard model and its extensions) Chapter 5 is an overview of methods to handle categorical time-to-event data. Chapters 6 and 9 cover overviews of Bayesian methods applied to time-to-event data and graphical approaches respectively. These chapters read like they are part of an introductory text and they have large reference lists for very pertinent and up-to-date articles and books. The other chapters are mostly specialized topics such as chapter 8 by Bhore and Huque on the estimation and and testing of a change in the hazard rate in the survival curve.
I particularly like the book because it provides a refresher course that also includes new approaches or old ones that I am not so familiar with. It is a very important and authoritative text that any statistician doing time-to-event trials can rely on.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials with Time-to-Event Endpoints (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)

Using time-to-event analysis methodology requires careful definition of the event, censored observation, provision of adequate follow-up, number of events, and independence or "noninformativeness" of the censoring mechanisms relative to the event. Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials with Time-to-Event Endpoints provides a thorough presentation of the design, monitoring, analysis, and interpretation of clinical trials in which time-to-event is of critical interest.After reviewing time-to-event endpoint methodology, clinical trial issues, and the design and monitoring of clinical trials, the book focuses on inferential analysis methods, including parametric, semiparametric, categorical, and Bayesian methods; an alternative to the Cox model for small samples; and estimation and testing for change in hazard. It then presents descriptive and graphical methods useful in the analysis of time-to-event endpoints. The next several chapters explore a variety of clinical trials, from analgesic, antibiotic, and antiviral trials to cardiovascular and cancer prevention, prostate cancer, astrocytoma brain tumor, and chronic myelogonous leukemia trials. The book then covers areas of drug development, medical practice, and safety assessment. It concludes with the design and analysis of clinical trials of animals required by the FDA for new drug applications.Drawing on the expert contributors' experiences working in biomedical research and clinical drug development, this comprehensive resource covers an array of time-to-event methods and explores an assortment of real-world applications.

Buy NowGet 14% OFF

Click here for more information about Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials with Time-to-Event Endpoints (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)

Read More...

9/01/2012

Biostatistics: Experimental Design and Statistical Inference Review

Biostatistics: Experimental Design and Statistical Inference
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
What makes this book stand out from other books on biostatistics is the 100 summarized and briefly critiqued experiments in the second half of the book. I found that critiquing the experiments and comparing to the author's critique dragged me kicking and screaming to a better understanding of statistics in biological experiments. The book has trained me to quickly review other experiments well.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Biostatistics: Experimental Design and Statistical Inference

This textbook takes a unique approach to explaining and demonstrating how to use and interpret statistics for the physiological, medical, and life sciences. The first third of the book presents an integrated overview and introduction to experimental design and statistical inference. The rest of the book provides an extensively cross-referenced set of 100 brief critiques of sample case studies embodying all the most common statistical errors or design problems found in the biological literature. These specific cases are effective for teaching the principles of biostatistics. The examples are drawn primarily from biomedicine, yet the book is also valuable to psychologists, social scientists, environmental scientists, ecologists, and any discipline employing statistics.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about Biostatistics: Experimental Design and Statistical Inference

Read More...

8/20/2012

Biostatistical Methods: The Assessment of Relative Risks (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics) Review

Biostatistical Methods: The Assessment of Relative Risks (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
John Lachin is Professor and Director of the graduate program in biostatistics at George Washington University. The book is intended as a first advanced course for students in that program. The book emphasizes methods for problems in biostatistics. To Lachin this means an emphasis on binary, categorical and survival data that relate to the assessment of risk and relative risk through clinical research. Consequently much of the standard parametric and nonparametric modeling of continuous response data is not considered.
A variety of methods are covered on a number of subjects. The first half of the book deals with classical approaches to single and multiple 2x2 contigency tables used in cross-sectional, prospective and case-control studies. In the second half, the more modern likelihood or model-based approach is presented. Technical mathematical details are covered in the appendix which is referenced throughout the text. The appendix deals with statistical theory (stochastic convergence results and other theory) but does not provide rigorous proofs of the theorems. Real probelms are presented and analyses are illustrated using procedures in SAS.
In the model-based sections, topics include logistic regression, Poisson regression, proportional hazard and multiplicative intensity models. The book is modern, well written, provides a good list of references, has extensive problem sets at the end of the chapters and employs case studies to illustrate the application of the methods. It is not a book for beginners. It is a great reference source for biostatisticians and epidemiologists as well as a fine text for a graduate-level course in biostatistics.


Click Here to see more reviews about: Biostatistical Methods: The Assessment of Relative Risks (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics)

Praise for the First Edition
". . . an excellent textbook . . . an indispensable reference for biostatisticians and epidemiologists."—International Statistical Institute
A new edition of the definitive guide to classical and modern methods of biostatistics
Biostatistics consists of various quantitative techniques that are essential to the description and evaluation of relationships among biologic and medical phenomena. Biostatistical Methods: The Assessment of Relative Risks, Second Edition develops basic concepts and derives an expanded array of biostatistical methods through the application of both classical statistical tools and more modern likelihood-based theories. With its fluid and balanced presentation, the book guides readers through the important statistical methods for the assessment of absolute and relative risks in epidemiologic studies and clinical trials with categorical, count, and event-time data.
Presenting a broad scope of coverage and the latest research on the topic, the author begins with categorical data analysis methods for cross-sectional, prospective, and retrospective studies of binary, polychotomous, and ordinal data. Subsequent chapters present modern model-based approaches that include unconditional and conditional logistic regression; Poisson and negative binomial models for count data; and the analysis of event-time data including the Cox proportional hazards model and its generalizations. The book now includes an introduction to mixed models with fixed and random effects as well as expanded methods for evaluation of sample size and power. Additional new topics featured in this Second Edition include:
Establishing equivalence and non-inferiority
Methods for the analysis of polychotomous and ordinal data, including matched data and the Kappa agreement index
Multinomial logistic for polychotomous data and proportional odds models for ordinal data
Negative binomial models for count data as an alternative to the Poisson model
GEE models for the analysis of longitudinal repeated measures and multivariate observations

Throughout the book, SAS is utilized to illustrate applications to numerous real-world examples and case studies. A related website features all the data used in examples and problem sets along with the author's SAS routines.
Biostatistical Methods, Second Edition is an excellent book for biostatistics courses at the graduate level. It is also an invaluable reference for biostatisticians, applied statisticians, and epidemiologists.

Buy NowGet 26% OFF

Click here for more information about Biostatistical Methods: The Assessment of Relative Risks (Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics)

Read More...

8/05/2012

The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and Prediction (Oxford Statistical Science Series) Review

The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and Prediction (Oxford Statistical Science Series)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
With the increase in cancer trials both in medical research and the pharmaceutical industry, medical diagnostic tests including medical imaging evaluations are being used more and more. There is a need for adjudication when radiologists disagree on a diagnosis and some standard statistical measures from other fields are finding new application.
This book provides a thorough background on the subject, the methodology and the applications. It is very clearly written and not overly technical. The methodology is the classical frequentist approach to statistical inference. Recently, Lyle Broemeling has published a book on this topic that takes exclusively the Bayesian approach and explains the Bayesian approach for those who are not acquainted with it. When dealing with predictions based on evolving data the Bayesian approach might be more natural. This would be the case in a clinical trial where the data is reviewed sequentially.
A particularly important part of diagnostic accuracy analysis is the area under the ROC curve. Pepe does an excellent job of covering that topic. This text is referenced often in Broemeling's book since it provides an excellent explanation of the same topics using the frequentist approach that he covers with the Bayesian approach.

Click Here to see more reviews about: The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and Prediction (Oxford Statistical Science Series)

This book describes statistical concepts and techniques for evaluating medical diagnostic tests and biomarkers for detecting disease. More generally, the techniques pertain to the statistical classification problem for predicting a dichotomous outcome. Measures for quantifying test accuracy are described including sensitivity, specificity, predictive values, diagnostic likelihood ratios and the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve that is commonly used for continuous and ordinal valued tests. Statistical procedures are presented for estimating and comparing them. Regression frameworks for assessing factors that influence test accuracy and for comparing tests while adjusting for such factors are presented. This book presents many worked examples of real data and should be of interest to practicing statisticians or quantitative researchers involved in the development of tests for classification or prediction in medicine.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and Prediction (Oxford Statistical Science Series)

Read More...

4/09/2012

Primer of Applied Regression & Analysis of Variance Review

Primer  of Applied Regression and Analysis of Variance
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Like all advanced stats books, this one has mathematical rigor and plenty of examples. But unlike the others, this one is written from the point of view of a biologist. You won't just learn the math, you'll learn how to make sense of the results. The title is a bit misleading. This is not a "primer" of statistics. But once you've learned the basic principles of statistics, this is THE book to learn about various kinds of ANOVAS and regressions.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Primer of Applied Regression & Analysis of Variance

Applicable for all statistics courses or practical use, teaches how to understand more advanced multivariate statistical methods, as well as how to use available software packages to get correct results. Study problems and examples culled from biomedical research illustrate key points. New to this edition: broadened coverage of ANOVA (traditional analysis of variance), the addition of ANCOVA (analysis of Co-Variance); updated treatment of available statistics software; 2 new chapters (Analysis of Variance Extensions and Mixing Regression and ANOVA: ANCOVA). (20010101)

Buy NowGet 16% OFF

Click here for more information about Primer of Applied Regression & Analysis of Variance

Read More...

3/06/2012

Medical Biostatistics (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series) Review

Medical Biostatistics (Chapman and Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I have long been looking for a book that makes biostatistics simple and readable to medical professionals. This book on Medical Biostatistics by Indrayan and Sarmukaddam (Marcel Dekker) is a very sincere attempt in making the subject of biostatistics look like a medical discipline. This is one of the objectives stated in the book, and seems to have been very adequately achieved. The language used is friendly to the medical fraternity. A large number of statistical methods have been discussed that are commonly used in medicine and health. Mathematics is minimal and explantions appeal to the common sense. Statistical fallacies are also discussed. Strongly recommended for all professionals and students of medical related disciplines who collect, disseminate or use data in any form.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Medical Biostatistics (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Medical Biostatistics (Chapman & Hall/CRC Biostatistics Series)

Read More...

2/12/2012

Modeling in Medical Decision Making: A Bayesian Approach (Statistics in Practice) Review

Modeling in Medical Decision Making: A Bayesian Approach (Statistics in Practice)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This is a nice readable book about decision theory from the Bayesian perspective. In addition to providing the foundations of Bayesian decision theory including utility theory the author prvides many real world research examples including meta-analyses.
Unlike his more recent and highly statistically sophisticated text on Bayesian decision theory this concentrates on medical examples and his written at a level to appeal to clinicians as well as statisticians. Decision trees and methods toevaluate quality of life years are introduced and used in the examples.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Modeling in Medical Decision Making: A Bayesian Approach (Statistics in Practice)



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Modeling in Medical Decision Making: A Bayesian Approach (Statistics in Practice)

Read More...

1/09/2012

Handbook of Statistics, Volume 27: Epidemiology and Medical Statistics Review

Handbook of Statistics, Volume 27: Epidemiology and Medical Statistics
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This series is a long and successful collection of volumes on the most important topics in statistics. Professor Krishnaiah from the University of Pittsburgh was one of the first editors. When the famous Professor C. R. Rao moved from India to the US he joined his colleague Krishnaiah at Pittsburgh and helped coedit some of these handbooks. After Krishnaiah's death Professor Rao continued to edit these volumes and brought in some of his colleagues as co-editors.
This is volume 27 and it contains 27 chapters on the topic of medical statistics and epidemiology. This is very important to me as I work in the medical research area.
The editors have assembly the leading experts in statistical methodology and applied biostatistical reserach to produce these 27 chapters.
Ross Prentice (coauthor of 2 edition of a book on survival analysis and the Cox model) wrote an overview chapter on the topics to be covered. He has had a long career at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle Washington. Fred Hutchinson was a famous manager for the Cincinnati Reds in the early 1960s and brought them to the World Series in 1961. He died of cancer and his estate started an endowment to form this research center.
Don Rubin covers causal analysis in Chapter 2. Rubin is an expert on causal inference, Bayesian methods and missing data. He presents the randomized trial approaches of Fisher and Neyman introduces propensity scores. A Bayesian approach is also covered.
Other chapters cover epidemiologic study designs, assessments for biomarkers, linear and nonlinear regression models, logistic regression, regression models for count data, mixed linear and nonlinear models, survival analysis, competing risk models, cluster analysis, factor analysis, structural equation models, crossover trials, group sequential methods, early phase trials (I and II), late phase (III and IV), missing data, Meta-Analysis, multiple comparisons, sample size determination
statistical learning using splines, evidence based medicine, marginal regression models, use of difference equations in modeling and the Bayesian approach to medical inference.
This volume is over 800 pages and each chapter is fairly long and includes large bibliographies.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Handbook of Statistics, Volume 27: Epidemiology and Medical Statistics



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Handbook of Statistics, Volume 27: Epidemiology and Medical Statistics

Read More...

12/29/2011

Statistical Methods in Medical Research (Armitage, Statistical Methods in Medical Research) Review

Statistical Methods in Medical Research (Armitage, Statistical Methods in Medical Research)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This is definitely one of the most comprehensive of all biostatistics textbooks out there and it is also the best. Authoritative in style, it starts from the very basics and surveys in *detail* almost every method in biostatistics.
You will be impressed: Apart from *all* the basic techniques usually found in most biostatistics texbooks, it has two extensive chapters on Bayesian methods (with Gibbs sampling, MCMC, etc., you name it), extensive treatments of clinical trials, extensive treatments of longitudinal data and GEE models, extensive details on the bootstrap and jackknife, an extensive chapter on methods in epidemiology (risk ratios, Mantel-Haenszel method), extensive treatments of categorical data (contingency tables, logistic regression), and an extensive chapter on survival analysis. This is indeed a very extensive book.
"Statistical Methods in Medical Research" is also a book on methodology, so theorems and proofs are not to be expected. Also there are no exercises, but there are excellent illustrative examples of the various methods. While it is very descriptive, it contains enough mathematics to keep the presentation of concepts *complete*. It is also very up-to-date and has an excellent reference list.
In a nutshell, this is a work of great ambition and vision: it will cater for beginners and masters alike.


Click Here to see more reviews about: Statistical Methods in Medical Research (Armitage, Statistical Methods in Medical Research)

The explanation and implementation of statistical methods for the medical researcher or statistician remains an integral part of modern medical research. This book explains the use of experimental and analytical biostatistics systems. Its accessible style allows it to be used by the non-mathematician as a fundamental component of successful research.
Since the third edition, there have been many developments in statistical techniques. The fourth edition provides the medical statistician with an accessible guide to these techniques and to reflect the extent of their usage in medical research.
The new edition takes a much more comprehensive approach to its subject. There has been a radical reorganization of the text to improve the continuity and cohesion of the presentation and to extend the scope by covering many new ideas now being introduced into the analysis of medical research data. The authors have tried to maintain the modest level of mathematical exposition that characterized the earlier editions, essentially confining the mathematics to the statement of algebraic formulae rather than pursuing mathematical proofs.
Received the Highly Commended Certificate in the Public Health Category of the 2002 BMA Books Competition.

Buy NowGet 14% OFF

Click here for more information about Statistical Methods in Medical Research (Armitage, Statistical Methods in Medical Research)

Read More...

12/18/2011

Principles of Medical Statistics Review

Principles of Medical Statistics
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Alvan Feinstein engraved his name in history through great improvements in medical biostatistics and research methodology just to name a couple. His last book (sadly) is a marvelous trip through medical statistics made very down to earth without loosing the scientific background, but rather explaining it in a very concrete and solid way. A wonderful book for anyone who seeks information on medical statistics. A great complement to his research and clinimetrics books.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Principles of Medical Statistics

The get-it-over-with-quickly approach to statistics has been encouraged - and often necessitated - by the short time allotted to it in most curriculums. If included at all, statistics is presented briefly, as a task to be endured mainly because pertinent questions may appear in subsequent examinations for licensure or other certifications. However, in later professional activities, clinicians and biomedical researchers will constantly be confronted with reports containing statistical expressions and analyses.Not just a set of cookbook recipes, Principles of Medical Statistics is designed to get you thinking about data and statistical procedures. It covers many new statistical methods and approaches like box plots, stem and leaf plots, concepts of stability, the bootstrap, and the jackknife methods of resampling. The book is arranged in a logical sequence that advances from simple to more elaborate results. The text describes all the conventional statistical procedures, and offers reasonably rigorous accounts of many of their mathematical justifications. Although the conventional mathematical principles are given a respectful account, the book provides a distinctly clinical orientation with examples and teaching exercises drawn from real world medical phenomena.Statistical procedures are an integral part of the basic background needed by biomedical researchers, students, and clinicians. Containing much more than most elementary texts, Principles of Medical Statistics fills the gap often found in the current curriculum. It repairs the imbalance that gives so little attention to the role of statistics as a prime component of basic biomedical education.

Buy NowGet 2% OFF

Click here for more information about Principles of Medical Statistics

Read More...

12/10/2011

Using and Understanding Medical Statistics Review

Using and Understanding Medical Statistics
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
For what this book intends, it truly is outstanding. In general, the medical researcher of any kind is at a severe disadvantage in dealing with professional biostatisticians because often the two do not speak a common language. This very readable, interesting and clearly written book gives the scientist enough knowledge to deal with most relatively simple cases in a language that we understand. With the basic principles of medical statistics made comprehensible, we are able to understand many of the simpler software packages well enough to perform basic statistical analyses and, more importantly, are able to converse intelligently with biostatistical professionals and to design studies that will pass muster. Unlike another reviewer, I do not feel that not covering SAS or other software programs is a disadvantage. No book can cover everything, and this book covers the basics and intermediate levels far better than any book I have seen, certainly better than any biostatistics book written by biostatisticians intended for other biostatisticians. This book understands that biostatistics is a tool, not a fundamental discipline, for the vast majority of scientists and is written to them. The book serves as a ready reference and review if one does not perform these analyses on a daily basis. This book should be on the shelf of every life scientist.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Using and Understanding Medical Statistics



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Using and Understanding Medical Statistics

Read More...

12/07/2011

Survival Analysis for Epidemiologic and Medical Research (Practical Guides to Biostatistics and Epidemiology) Review

Survival Analysis for Epidemiologic and Medical Research (Practical Guides to Biostatistics and Epidemiology)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
Ah, the shudder when a professor assigns his own book. But never fear, Steve Selvin, recipient of numerous teaching awards, is not publishing a book to line the faded jeans pocket, or to swell his balding curly head. Rather, it's just a practical way of printing his lecture notes and homeworks. Furthermore, its rare that a top research university professor has time to write textbooks, so the burden falls to the mediocre. Selvin somehow manages to find the time and save us from so many other books that screw up statistics.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Survival Analysis for Epidemiologic and Medical Research (Practical Guides to Biostatistics and Epidemiology)

This practical guide shows why the analytic methods work and how to effectively analyze and interpret epidemiologic and medical survival data with the help of modern computer systems. The introduction presents a review of a variety of statistical methods that are not only key elements of survival analysis but are also central to statistical analysis in general. Techniques such as statistical tests, transformations, confidence intervals, and analytic modeling are presented in the context of survival data but are, in fact, statistical tools that apply to understanding the analysis of many kinds of data. Similarly, discussions of such statistical concepts such as bias, confounding, independence, and interaction are presented in the context of survival analysis as well as the basic components of a broad range of applications.

Buy Now

Click here for more information about Survival Analysis for Epidemiologic and Medical Research (Practical Guides to Biostatistics and Epidemiology)

Read More...

11/13/2011

Practical Statistics for Medical Research (Chapman & Hall/CRC Texts in Statistical Science) Review

Practical Statistics for Medical Research (Chapman and Hall/CRC Texts in Statistical Science)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This is a very well written and popular text on biostatistics. Altman writes for non-statisticians but the book is best suited for those with at least one prior course in statistics and those who have had mathematics through high school algebra. Emphasis is placed on the important practical problems. Good statistical designs and analyses are emphasized. The pitfalls with many published medical articles are discussed in Chapter 16.
I used this book to teach a 20 lecture course to students (engineers, clinicians and computer scientists) at Pacesetter in 1998 and at Biosense Webster in 1999 (both medical device companies that employed me as senior biostatistician). It was a good refresher course for the CRAs and engineers and it helped to make it easier for me to work with them on their statistical problems.
I have also taught a similar course to undergraduate students in the Health Science Department at Cal State Long Beach. Altman's book is a little too advanced to use as a text for that course but I did use it as a reference and covered material in Chapter 16 at the end of the course. Clear discussion of the medical literature is very important to these students and Altman does a great job!


Click Here to see more reviews about: Practical Statistics for Medical Research (Chapman & Hall/CRC Texts in Statistical Science)

Most medical researchers, whether clinical or non-clinical, receive some background in statistics as undergraduates. However, it is most often brief, a long time ago, and largely forgotten by the time it is needed. Furthermore, many introductory texts fall short of adequately explaining the underlying concepts of statistics, and often are divorced from the reality of conducting and assessing medical research.Practical Statistics for Medical Research is a problem-based text for medical researchers, medical students, and others in the medical arena who need to use statistics but have no specialized mathematics background. The author draws on twenty years of experience as a consulting medical statistician to provide clear explanations to key statistical concepts, with a firm emphasis on practical aspects of designing and analyzing medical research. The text gives special attention to the presentation and interpretation of results and the many real problems that arise in medical research.

Buy NowGet 13% OFF

Click here for more information about Practical Statistics for Medical Research (Chapman & Hall/CRC Texts in Statistical Science)

Read More...

10/15/2011

Private Guns, Public Health Review

Private Guns, Public Health
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
I got this hoping for a dispassionate, empirical review of the literature on guns and violence from a pro-control perspective. Unfortunately, the reasoning is far too weak to make this the "definitive" work that other reviewers described.
As an example, Hemenway argues that Gary Kleck's estimate of 2.5 million defensive gun uses (DGUs) per year is wrong. He spends one sentence describing Kleck's methodology, then tries to show that his estimate of DGUs against burglars, 845000, was impossibly high. He calculates a "more reasonable" estimate of 20000, by taking the number reported to police for a single city over a single four-month period, multiplying this number by 3 (to get an annual rate) and scaling it to the entire population of the US. He does not examine whether his sample is representative for the entire country over the entire year. He also does not consider that DGUs which go unreported to the police would be missing from his estimate. In fact, he implicitly assumes that all DGUs are reported to the National Crime Victim Survey and the police, and uses this assumption to force the contradictions he needs. Based on this discrepancy between Kleck's estimate and his own, and a few more equally fallacious comparisons, Hemenway triumphantly dismisses Kleck's work as "not plausible," "a vast overestimate," "grossly exaggerated," and "the most outrageous number mentioned in a policy discussion by an elected official." Hemenway also makes no mention of the 15 other surveys with similar DGU estimates cited by Kleck, yet still asserts that "all attempts at external validation [of Kleck's estimate] reveal it to be a huge overestimate."
This kind of sloppy deduction from unstated (and doubtful) assumptions completely destroyed the author's credibility. This example is typical of his logic throughout the book. The worst part is that even when his arguments are logical, he rarely cites any references, so we have no way to ascertain the reliability of his evidence.
A note about the positive reviews: all but one appear to have been written by markkarlin, as after he wrote the first five-star review, there were six more over the next few days, all written anonymously.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Private Guns, Public Health



Buy Now

Click here for more information about Private Guns, Public Health

Read More...

9/04/2011

Gun Violence: The Real Costs (Studies in Crime and Public Policy) Review

Gun Violence: The Real Costs (Studies in Crime and Public Policy)
Average Reviews:

(More customer reviews)
This book is obviously strongly on our side, but unfortunately it is not going to provide us with serious evidence. Suppose someone challenges me on how they got their $100 billion estimate of the costs of guns. Will I be taken seriously if I tell them that the book relies on one public survey question in one survey? If I do use this number, where does that leave me in arguing with gun nuts that cite these wacky surveys showing that guns are used defensively 2.5 million times a year? So they have 16 surveys. I don't believe any of them, but what do I say when they say I only use a survey to measure the costs, why not also the benefits? What if the gun nut morons point out that the estimates of benefits from the surveys are greater than our estimated costs? The one paragraph that Cook and Ludwig have on defensive gun uses being silly could just as well be used against their reliance on a survey. I want to use the figures here, but could one of the people on our side write a review saying how I could respond to these concerns. Absent that this book risks making us look rather silly and hypocritical.

Click Here to see more reviews about: Gun Violence: The Real Costs (Studies in Crime and Public Policy)



Buy NowGet 13% OFF

Click here for more information about Gun Violence: The Real Costs (Studies in Crime and Public Policy)

Read More...